Showing posts with label ben bernanke. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ben bernanke. Show all posts

Thursday, November 22, 2007

Market bets on lower interest rates on growth concerns

Fed Forecasts Spur Traders to Ignore Warnings on Cuts (Update1)

By Scott Lanman

Nov. 21 (Bloomberg) -- The Federal Reserve's first set of quarterly economic forecasts fueled speculation that it will cut interest rates again, contrary to warnings by policy makers in the past two weeks.

The degree of ``uncertainty'' about the growth outlook is greater than that for inflation, officials said in a supplement to minutes of their October meeting released yesterday. While officials expressed confidence price increases will ease, they viewed markets as ``still fragile and were concerned that an adverse shock'' would worsen economic risks.

The wariness about a continued credit collapse pushed odds of a rate cut next month up to 92 percent, according to federal funds futures, from as low as 70 percent. Investors differ with Chairman Ben S. Bernanke and other officials, who have said this month that the dangers of a slower expansion and faster inflation were ``roughly'' balanced.

``Risks aren't balanced,'' said Michael Feroli, a former Fed board staff member who is now an economist at JPMorgan Chase & Co. in New York. ``Recent developments in financial markets increase the likelihood that they will ease.''

Treasuries climbed today, sending yields on 10-year notes below 4 percent for the first time in two years as investors flocked to the safety of government debt.

As part of its new release on the three-year economic estimates of Fed governors and district-bank presidents, the central bank discussed risks to the outlook. ``Most participants judged that the uncertainty attending'' their growth forecasts ``was above typical levels seen in the past,'' the Fed said.

Growth Forecast

Officials predicted growth will slow to as low as 1.8 percent in 2008, according to the middle range of projections. That would be the weakest since the 2001 recession. The Fed's historical estimates indicate that the actual expansion is likely to be within 1.3 percentage points above or below the estimate.

In June, policy makers anticipated 2.5 percent to 2.75 percent growth next year. Officials left their projection for inflation, excluding food and energy costs, little changed at a 1.7 percent to 1.9 percent pace for the next two years.

``The focus in the minutes is on the downside risks to growth,'' which contrasts with an ``optimistic inflation forecast,'' said Robert Eisenbeis, the former head of research at the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta. ``They clearly will respond if needed.''

Rate Cuts

The Federal Open Market Committee lowered its benchmark rate by a quarter point on Oct. 31, to 4.5 percent, after reducing borrowing costs a half point in September.

Since the meeting, banks have warned of billions of dollars of losses on debt tied to subprime mortgages. Stocks have also retreated, while the number of private economists predicting a recession has risen, according to the National Association for Business Economics.

While the ``most likely'' scenario is consumer spending and business investment rise at a ``moderate'' pace, Fed officials recognized a market shock ``could further dent investor confidence and significantly increase the downside risks,'' the minutes said.

Such a disruption could come from ``a sharp deterioration in credit quality or disclosure of unusually large and unanticipated losses,'' the Fed said.

In their speeches and public remarks, policy makers have said they expect growth to accelerate by the middle of 2008 and warned that surging energy and commodity prices, and a falling dollar, may push up inflation.

`Rough Patch'

Economic reports confirming a ``rough patch'' in the economy ``would not, by themselves, suggest to me that the current stance of monetary policy is inappropriate,'' Fed Governor Randall Kroszner said Nov. 16. Further rate cuts may increase the risk inflation will accelerate, he signaled.

Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis President William Poole said in a Nov. 15 interview with Dow Jones that ``there can only be chaos'' if the Fed follows traders' expectations in setting policy.

``When you think about the effects of monetary policy, you are going to be thinking about several quarters ahead,'' said Douglas Elmendorf, a former assistant director of the Fed's research and statistics division who is now a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington. ``The FOMC is very focused on maintaining and building their credibility on keeping inflation low.''

Yesterday's forecasts are the product of a 1 1/2-year review commissioned by Bernanke to improve how the Fed communicates its policy objectives. He said in a Nov. 14 speech that the new reports will help show ``how our policy decisions respond to incoming information and will enhance our accountability.''

Less Optimistic

Fed policy makers are less optimistic about the 2008 expansion rate than private economists. The median Fed estimate of about 2.25 percent is less than the 2.4 percent consensus prediction of the Blue Chip survey of forecasters. Four of 17 Fed governors and presidents expect growth of 1.8 percent or less.

Fed officials will have more opportunities to send investors a message before the Dec. 11 meeting. Next week, at least four regional-bank presidents speak, including Philadelphia's Charles Plosser and William Poole of St. Louis. Bernanke speaks Nov. 29 at an event in Charlotte, North Carolina.

``There is a very slow movement toward understanding the severity of financial market problems and the impact on the economy,'' said Kurt Karl, chief U.S. economist at Swiss Reinsurance Co. in New York. ``The question is, what is the Fed waiting for?''

Monday, November 19, 2007

Bond markets tell a different story

Bond Market to Bernanke: Recession Threat Means More Rate Cuts

By Daniel Kruger

Nov. 19 (Bloomberg) -- The headline in the financial futures market these days says Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke is withholding some vital information: The economy is so bad the central bank will have to lower interest rates at least three- quarters of a percentage point to avoid a recession.

Bernanke's two rate cuts since September failed to reassure the bond market, where volatility has risen four of the past five weeks, according to Merrill Lynch & Co.'s MOVE Index. Yields on Treasury bills, the haven for bond investors in times of turmoil, are near their lows of August, when losses on securities backed by subprime mortages froze credit markets.

While the record low dollar and the fastest inflation in 14 months give policy makers reasons to keep the target rate for overnight loans between banks at 4.5 percent, traders expect 3.75 percent early in 2008. Interest-rate futures on the Chicago Board of Trade show the Fed will cut borrowing costs in December and again in the first quarter, as the worst housing slump since 1991 deepens and retailers including J.C. Penney Co. and Macy's Inc. forecast slumping sales.

Investors are sending the message to Bernanke that ``you're wrong and we're going to lead you to the next ease,'' said Thomas Tucci, head of U.S. government bond trading in New York at RBC Capital Markets. The firm is the investment-banking arm of Canada's biggest bank.

Fed fund futures show traders see a 90 percent chance the central bank will reduce its target a quarter-percentage point to 4.25 percent at its Dec. 11 meeting, 67 percent odds of another 25-basis-point cut in January, and a 43 percent likelihood the rate falls to 3.75 percent in March. Policy makers already lowered the target from 5.25 percent in August.

Worse than LTCM

The Fed hasn't cut that much since 2001, when the economy shrank and policy makers lowered rates 11 times. Even when Russia defaulted and Long-Term Capital Management LP collapsed in 1998, policy makers only had to reduce rates 75 basis points.

The yield on the benchmark two-year note, the security most sensitive to rate expectations, fell 8.5 basis points last week to 3.34 percent, according to bond broker Cantor Fitzgerald LP. The price of the 3 5/8 percent Treasury due in October 2009 rose 4/32, or $1.25 per $1,000 face amount, to 100 17/32. The benchmark 10-year note yield declined 5 basis points, or 0.05 percentage point, to 4.17 percent.

Bernanke suggested the central bank is reluctant to lower rates again when he told Congress on Nov. 8 that the economy will likely ``slow noticeably'' this quarter while also citing ``upside risks'' to inflation. Fed Governor Randall Kroszner was more pointed, saying in a New York speech on Nov. 16 that ``the current stance of monetary policy should help the economy get through the rough patch during the next year.''

Stiglitz `Pessimistic'

Financial markets aren't buying it. Wells Fargo & Co. Chief Executive Officer John Stumpf said at a Merrill Lynch conference in New York on Nov. 15 that the housing market slump is the worst since the Great Depression.

Joseph Stiglitz, the Columbia University professor and Nobel-prize winning economist, said there is a 50 percent chance of a recession in the U.S. as a worldwide increase in credit costs following the collapse of the subprime mortgage market chokes off financing. ``I'm very pessimistic,'' Stiglitz said in an interview in London Nov. 16.

Financial companies may lose as much as $400 billion because of home foreclosures, based on a ``back-of-the-envelope'' calculation, Jan Hatzius, chief U.S. economist at Goldman Sachs Group Inc. in New York, wrote in a report last week. That will force banks, brokerages and hedge funds to cut lending by $2 trillion, he estimated.

Bill Yields

Merrill's MOVE index reached 112.08 on Nov. 9, the highest since Sept. 20, and was at 99.14 on Nov. 16. The gap between yields on three-month bills and the Fed's target rate widened to 1.25 percentage points, the biggest gap since Sept. 14. Bill yields fell as low as 3.16 percent on Nov. 15, near this year's low of 3.09 percent on Aug. 20.

For the first time since 2001, yields on Treasuries maturing from three months to 10 years are below the federal funds rate. Five of the past six times that has happened, the economy entered a recession, data compiled by Bloomberg show.

Most analysts don't expect a recession. After annual growth of 3.9 percent from July to September, the economy will cool to a 1.5 percent pace this quarter and expand 2 percent in the first three months of 2008, according to the median estimate of 72 economists surveyed by Bloomberg from Nov. 1 to Nov. 8. The Fed will cut its target to 4.25 percent next quarter and leave it there through 2008, a separate survey shows.

Faster Inflation

Faster inflation is making Bernanke's job tougher. Consumer prices rose at a 3.5 percent annual rate in October, the most in 14 months, the Commerce Department said Nov. 15. Crude oil soared 56 percent this year, reaching a record $98.62 a barrel. The dollar sank to a record low of $1.4752 per euro on Nov. 9 and import prices rose 1.8 percent in October, the most in 17 months, the Labor Department said.

``It seems like there's an awful lot of price pressures,'' said Jamie Jackson, who oversees government debt trading at RiverSource Investments, a Minneapolis firm that manages $100 billion of bonds. ``It's harder to be a credible inflation fighter if you ease into accelerating inflation.''

The Fed is done cutting rates and 10-year yields may reach 4.75 percent next quarter, Jackson said.

Futures traders are betting the slump in housing and losses in credit markets will reduce consumer confidence and trump the threat of inflation, which erodes Treasuries' fixed payments.

`Saving the Economy'

``The Fed will not only need to save the financial markets, in very short order they're going to have to start saving the economy,'' said Tom di Galoma, head of Treasury trading in New York at Jefferies & Co., a brokerage for institutional investors. The 10-year yield will fall below 4 percent by the end of June and two-year yields to 3 percent, he said.

Homebuilding declined 20 percent last quarter, the seventh straight drop, subtracting a percentage point from economic growth, government data show. The National Association of Home Builders/Wells Fargo may say today that its index of builder sentiment fell to 17 this month from an all-time low of 18 in October, according to the median forecast in a Bloomberg News survey. The index averaged 42 last year.

Plano, Texas-based J.C. Penney, the third biggest U.S. department-store company, cut its fourth-quarter profit prediction by as much as a third last week. Macy's, based in Cincinnati, lowered its fourth-quarter sales guidance.

``The Fed tends to be backward looking,'' said Lacy Hunt, chief economist at Austin, Texas-based Hoisington Investment Management Co., which is buying zero-coupon and 30-year Treasuries, the most bullish bets that inflation will cool. ``They're always looking at the way the world was, not the way it will be. Market rates reflect the buying and selling decisions of millions and millions of decision-makers.''

Hunt predicts the Fed may lower its target to 2 percent in the next few years.

Thursday, November 15, 2007

Bernanke's new approach

Bernanke's Embrace of Forecasting Ends Greenspan `Decoder' Era

By Craig Torres

Nov. 15 (Bloomberg) -- Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke's decision to publish more details about the outlook for economic growth and prices represents a break with the legacy of Alan Greenspan and the cryptic phrases he used to signal policy.

``If you haven't thrown out your Greenspan decoder ring by now, you should,'' said Ethan Harris, chief U.S. economist at Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc., a former head of domestic research at the New York Federal Reserve Bank. ``Ben Bernanke is a very straight shooter. He tells it like it is. There are no hidden messages.''

Bernanke said yesterday that Fed officials will add a third year to their forecasts and double the frequency to once a quarter. The reports will give investors and companies more details on why interest rates were adjusted and offer a map for where they are likely to go.

Analysis will shift to how the committee sees the outlook, away from trying to guess where the chairman stands, as was the case during Greenspan's 18 years at the helm, Fed-watchers said.

``He wants the committee to function like a committee,'' said former Fed Vice Chairman Alan Blinder, now a professor at Princeton University in New Jersey. ``He doesn't want to dictate.'' Greenspan declined to comment.

Bernanke's forecasting overhaul brings the Fed closer to international central-bank practices and comes at a time of diverging views between policy makers and investors.

Rate Expectations

Bernanke and other Fed officials have repeatedly underscored their confidence the economy will accelerate by mid- 2008 after a lull this quarter. That hasn't stopped traders from assuming the central bank will cut rates at least once more after lowering borrowing costs in September and October.

Futures markets show a 72 percent probability the Fed will cut the benchmark rate a quarter-point to 4.25 percent Dec. 11.

Bernanke, 53, took office in February 2006 having pushed for increased transparency when he served as a Fed governor. Yesterday's announcement was the product of his 1 1/2-year review of Fed communication, and it fell short of the formal inflation target that Bernanke advocated as an academic.

At the same time Bernanke spoke on the changes, the Federal Open Market Committee released a statement detailing the new practices, illustrating that the decision was made jointly among policy makers.

`Diversity of Views'

Bernanke praised the ``diversity of views'' among the 12 district-bank presidents and seven Fed governors, who discuss rate decisions at FOMC meetings. He said the range of opinions ``serves to limit the risk that a single viewpoint or analytical framework might become unduly dominant,'' a frequent criticism of Greenspan's chairmanship.

The Fed chief also took questions from the press after his remarks yesterday, another break from Greenspan, who avoided public exchanges with reporters.

In his speech, Bernanke framed transparency as critical to the central bank's ``democratic legitimacy'' with the public, Congress and financial markets -- constituents that critics say the Fed hasn't always served in a balanced way.

``If he wants to translate the dynamics of what makes the economy change in a language that ordinary people can understand, I think that is sensational,'' said William Greider, author of the 1987 book Secrets of the Temple, which described the Fed's secretiveness as ``the crucial anomaly at the very core of representative democracy.''

Greenspan Continuity

Bernanke did note continuity with Greenspan's incremental steps. The central bank first began announcing rate changes in 1994 and later issued statements after every meeting. Greenspan also oversaw a speeding up of FOMC meeting minutes releases, to a three-week lag instead of six.

The more-frequent outlooks will bring the Fed in line with the European Central Bank and counterparts in the U.K., Sweden and New Zealand, which publish quarterly projections. The Bank of Japan puts out a twice-yearly report.

Bernanke indicated yesterday was a first, not final, step in his efforts. The Fed still trails other central banks in openness in access to the media, as the Fed chairman doesn't give on-the-record interviews or press conferences.

Bernanke put Vice Chairman Donald Kohn, a former Greenspan adviser who was at odds with the chairman's views on the merits of inflation targeting, in charge of the communications project. The decision insulated the committee from the chairman's direct influence, with San Francisco Fed President Janet Yellen and the Minneapolis Fed's Gary Stern being the other members.

Forecast Dates

Fed officials will release their quarterly forecasts in minutes of FOMC meetings in January, April, June and October. The publications will include commentary on officials' thoughts about the risks to their projections, Bernanke said.

The first new predictions come Nov. 20, offering investors a glimpse of the Fed's most recent reading on the economy three weeks before it meets.

``This is depersonalizing monetary policy,'' said Vincent Reinhart, former director of the Fed's monetary affairs division, who worked with Bernanke on the plan and is now at the American Enterprise Institute in Washington.

``When he talks about the outlook, it is going to be the him talking about the committee's'' forecasts, he said, referring to Bernanke. ``Greenspan's testimony almost never referred to those numbers. It was his outlook.''

Friday, October 5, 2007

The Fed's moral hazard

Bernanke Stumped by Representative Ron Paul
Scott Reamer
Sep 20, 2007 3:57 pm

In today’s testimony before the house, Fed Chairman Bernanke was questioned by Representative Ron Paul in what was a remarkable exchange. Remarkable for how straightforward, lucid, and anti-statist the question was. In his questioning, Ron Paul stated:

“I want to follow up on the discussion about moral hazard. I think we have a very narrow understanding about what moral hazard really is. Because I think moral hazard begins at the very moment that we create artificially low interest rates which we constantly do. And this is the reason people make mistakes. It isn’t because human nature causes us to make all these mistakes, but there is a normal reaction when interest rates are low that there will be overinvestment and malinvestment, excessive debt, and then there are consequences from this. My question is going to be around the subject of how can it ever be morally justifiable to deliberately depreciate the value of our currency?”

His statements continued (about how much oil, gold, wheat, corn, etc. has gone up since the rate decrease) but the heart of his question was the following moral question: ...consciously depreciating the value of the USD has winners and losers (Wall Street/banks/the rich and everyone else), Mr. Bernanke. How do you constantly choose Wall Street over the rest of America?

You will not be surprised to know that B-52 Ben didn’t answer the question. He couldn’t answer the question (at least truthfully). Was he going to say that the Federal Reserve is a quasi-private institution whose prime directive is to cartelize and protect the profits of the banking industry? Was he going to say that the only policy the Fed knows is based on the flawed Keynesian logic that wealth can be created out of thin air via printing presses? Of course not.But his non-answer is not germane. The element that Ron Paul introduced is: the morality of the Federal Reserve’s constant injection of credit into the system at the slightest hint of macroeconomic distress. And I mean slightest: we haven’t even seen a GDP print below 0. We were only down 4.2% from the ALL TIME high in the Dow (the Fed’s own research suggests that the stock market is the best leading indicator of the economy).

Back in July of 2006, I wrote a piece introducing this moral element into the discussion of the Federal Reserve’s monetary policies. I wrote then words that today, after a pre-emptive, forestalling 50 basis points decrease and more than $1 trillion in worldwide central bank injections of credit, are as germane as ever:

“A constant loss of value in the monetary unit forces all manner of dire consequences on economic actors: it favors consumption over saving, speculation over investment, capital over labor, and the young over the old; it prevents accurate economic calculation about the future and thus clouds investment horizons; it hollows out a country's middle class making for more class conflict between haves and have nots… there are grave time preference consequences as well that impact not only long term investment projects (as noted above) but also the very manner in which parents raise their children and how children care for their ageing parents, as well as the lessons of frugality and hard work that once were the bedrock of this nation.”

Bravo to Ron Paul for giving voice to the hundreds of millions or pensioners, savers, working stiffs, poor, fixed income beneficiaries, laborers, gasoline-, bread-, milk-, and egg-buyers who weren’t able to ask Mr. Bernanke why he – like every Fed chairman before him since 1913 – screwed them for the benefit of the top 5% of the population of this country.

Tuesday, September 4, 2007

Heard from Jackson Hole

Bernanke's Pledge Fails to Dispel Pessimism at Jackson Retreat
By John Fraher and Scott Lanman


Sept. 3 (Bloomberg) -- Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke's pledge to stop the credit-market rout from wrecking the economy failed to quell concern at the Fed's Wyoming summer retreat that the U.S. is heading for recession.

``I came to Jackson Hole thinking there would be no recession, but I'm leaving thinking we could well have one,'' said Susan Wachter, a professor at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School, who co-wrote the first academic paper presented at the conference.

This year's theme -- Bernanke said organizers had ``outdone themselves'' with a relevant topic -- was housing and monetary policy, eliciting forecasts of sliding home prices and criticism the Fed should have done more. Martin Feldstein of Harvard University warned of a ``very serious downturn'' and called on policy makers to cut interest rates by 1 percentage point.

The normally academic tone of the Kansas City Fed's symposium was replaced this year by concern that the sudden increase in the cost of credit to people and companies will hurt spending and investment. Consumer confidence dropped by the most in two years in August, the Conference Board reported on Aug. 28.

``There are no optimists in the crowd here,'' said Ethan Harris, chief U.S. economist at Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. in New York and a former head of domestic research at the New York Fed. ``There's a pretty strong consensus that this has gotten a lot more serious.''

As officials and professors debated lessons from the housing slump, New York Fed President Timothy Geithner and Governor Randall Kroszner were spotted on their mobile phones. Geithner is the central bank's liaison to Wall Street, while Kroszner heads the Fed board's banking supervision committee.

`Very Serious'
``The economy could suffer a very serious downturn,'' Feldstein, president of the National Bureau of Economic Research in Cambridge, Massachusetts, told the conference. The NBER dates American economic cycles. The last recession was from March to November 2001.
Bernanke, dressed in a dark grey suit that stood out from the typical dress of polo shirts, jeans and khakis at the Grand Tetons gathering, said in the opening speech that the Fed will ``act as needed'' to protect the expansion.

That didn't assuage critics such as Edward Leamer, the head of an economic forecasting group at the University of California at Los Angeles. He wrote in one of the conference papers that the Fed merited an `F' for failing to prevent the housing bubble and then not reducing rates as it burst.

`Lesser of Two Evils'
Feldstein called for ``a major reduction now in the federal funds rate, possibly by as much as'' 1 percentage point from the current level of 5.25 percent. While that may push up inflation, it's the ``lesser of two evils,'' he said in a Sept. 1 speech.

Fed policy makers next meet on Sept. 18. While central banks pumped $350 billion in emergency funds into money markets last month, signs of stress continue.

Commercial paper, a short-term financing tool, declined by $244.1 billion, or 11 percent, in the three weeks to Aug. 29, the most in at least seven years, Fed data show. Three-month Treasury bill yields had their biggest drop since 2001 in August as investors sought safety in government debt.

Delinquencies on subprime mortgages, the origin of the turmoil, are likely to climb further as variable-rate loans reset higher, Bernanke said.

Even so, ``global financial losses have far exceeded even the most pessimistic projections of credit losses on those loans,'' he said. That's because of difficulties in setting prices for complex securities and concerns that housing will hold back economic growth, the Fed chief said.

`Gloomy as I'
``I rather expected that I would come out and find that people weren't quite as gloomy as I was, and I didn't find that,'' said former Fed Governor Lyle Gramley, now a senior economic adviser at Stanford Group Co. in Washington. ``So it confirmed my own concerns about the economy.''

Attendees nevertheless sounded confident that the global economy, which has relied on the U.S. to drive growth for much of the past decade, is strong enough to cope with the slowdown.

In China, where the economy expanded at the fastest pace in more than 12 years in the second quarter, manufacturing unexpectedly quickened in August. While business confidence in Germany, Europe's largest economy, fell last month, it was still better than most economists had forecast.

``The world economy is still very robust and growth is much more evenly spread than it was a few years ago,'' Otmar Issing, former chief economist at the European Central Bank, said in an interview.

That was little comfort to most at the conference as they debated the impact of the housing recession on consumer spending, in between hikes along trails near Yellowstone Park.

Yale University professor Robert Shiller said house prices in some U.S. cities may fall by as much as half, while Leamer predicted declines in some areas of 30 percent to 40 percent. Feldstein saw the chance of a ``substantial decline'' in spending because consumers won't be able to borrow as much against the value of their homes.

Tuesday, August 21, 2007

"Rookie" mistake?

Bernanke's `Rookie Mistake' Forces Fed to Shift Focus (Update2)
By Craig Torres


Aug. 20 (Bloomberg) -- Federal Reserve policy makers, who declared that inflation was their paramount challenge just two weeks ago, have been forced to make financial-market stability the trigger for changes in interest rates.

By lowering the discount rate and issuing a statement conceding threats to the economy, Federal Open Market Committee members effectively ripped up the economic-outlook statement from their Aug. 7 meeting. Some economists describe the about-face, coming after months of assurances that the subprime-mortgage rout was contained, as Chairman Ben S. Bernanke's first serious error since taking office last year.

``It was a rookie mistake,'' said Kenneth Thomas, a lecturer in finance at the University of Pennsylvania's Wharton School in Philadelphia. The Fed ``underestimated liquidity needs'' of investors and the fallout from the housing recession, he said, adding, ``This demonstrates the difference between book-smart and street-smart.''

Bernanke, a former chairman of the economics department at Princeton University, has elevated the role of forecasts in Fed policy rather than amassing clues from dozens of market indicators as predecessor Alan Greenspan did. The Fed forecasts showed that ``moderate'' growth would continue, and that inflation remained the biggest danger. The credit collapse has undermined that stance, and Bernanke may cut the benchmark interest rate by at least a quarter-point at or before the Sept. 18 FOMC meeting, analysts say.

Tough to Model
``Sometimes, the dynamics change very, very quickly,'' said former Fed governor Laurence Meyer, who voted for the three reductions in 1998 after currencies in Asia, Russia and Latin America tumbled. Bernanke's shift ``tells us how difficult it is to translate financial turbulence into the macroeconomic forecast.''

The Fed on Aug. 17 lowered its discount rate -- what it charges banks for direct loans -- by 0.5 percentage point to 5.75 percent, in an effort to increase liquidity in longer-term loans and bonds.

The initial request for the move came from Fed district banks in New York and San Francisco. They are led respectively by Timothy Geithner and Janet Yellen, both former Clinton administration officials who dealt with the 1997-1998 currency crises. The Fed's Board of Governors in Washington is dominated by academics.

Meyer's Call
Meyer, vice chairman of Macroeconomic Advisors LLC in Washington, recommended prior to the Aug. 7 FOMC meeting that policy makers cease describing inflation as the biggest risk. By saying the risks to growth and inflation were roughly equal, the central bank would have given itself room to maneuver if markets -- already weakening -- continued to slide.

The committee said in its statement three days ago that ``the downside risks to growth have increased appreciably'' because of the tumult in markets. Officials abandoned the prediction of a ``moderate'' expansion, and inflation wasn't mentioned.

While leaving the main rate at 5.25 percent, the panel said it is ``prepared to act as needed to mitigate the adverse effects on the economy.''

Stocks rallied after the announcement, but credit markets remained unsettled. The Standard & Poor's 500 Index climbed 2.5 percent, the biggest rally in four years. By contrast, asset backed commercial paper yields jumped the most since the Sept. 11, 2001, terrorist attacks. Top-rated paper maturing Aug. 20 yielded 5.99 percent late on Aug. 17, up 39 basis points in a day. A basis point is 0.01 percentage point.

Most Since 1987
Today, stocks are falling and Treasuries climbing. The yield on three-month Treasury bills slid the most since 1987 as investors sought a haven in short-dated, government-guaranteed debt. The S&P 500 fell 0.7 percent to 1,435.23 at 2:23 p.m. in New York.

``The Fed has an easing bias, but it is not an easing bias dictated strictly by economic conditions,'' said Stephen Stanley, chief economist at RBS Greenwich Capital Markets in Greenwich, Connecticut. ``This is a financial-market issue, which is then bleeding into the economy.''
Last week's policy shift notwithstanding, Bernanke's moves to resolve the credit crunch so far have been restrained. Even then, and unlike the Greenspan era, it was the Fed doing the talking, not any one individual.

Injecting Cash
The Fed pumped $38 billion into the banking system on Aug. 10 to free up financing in short-term credit markets, and issued a six-line statement. The injection was the Fed's biggest since the meltdown began. By contrast, the European Central Bank added $130 billion in temporary reserves a day earlier. ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet followed up with media interviews designed to reassure investors.
``We're getting a nice further look at the new Bernanke Fed,'' said Ethan Harris, chief U.S. economist at Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. in New York. ``He definitely wants to use the committee and these more formal directives,'' as opposed to Greenspan's preference for speeches laden with ``code words.''

The reduction in the discount rate, which is used less than the federal funds rate as a policy-making tool, wasn't directed at the broad economy so much as at trying to ease gridlock in credit markets. The Fed said it would accept everything from home-equity loans to municipal bonds as collateral for discount- window loans up to 30 days.

`Calamity' Needed
The decision to keep the benchmark overnight lending rate unchanged -- for now -- may be a sign that the central bank is still wary of bailing out bad bets by financial institutions and investors. St. Louis Fed President William Poole said in an interview on Aug. 15 that only a ``calamity'' would justify a rate cut between scheduled FOMC meetings.

``They knew what they were doing'' by maintaining the anti- inflation bias at their Aug. 7 meeting, said former Dallas Fed President Robert McTeer. ``I do not agree with it, but I think they were trying very hard not to have a Bernanke put. They were hard-pressed to keep that out of it. It became unrealistic.''

Traders and economists use the term ``Greenspan put'' to describe the priority the former chairman placed on financial- market stability. A put option provides the right, though not the obligation, to sell a security, currency or commodity within a set period.

Greenspan provided ample liquidity after the 1987 stock market crash, and he was one of the architects who arranged a financial backstop for Mexico after the 1994 peso devaluation. In 1998, the Fed also helped oversee the rescue of failed hedge fund Long Term Capital Management, and cut interest rates 75 basis points in three separate moves to cushion the blow of global financial turmoil.

Abandoning Forecasts
Former Fed officials say it's difficult for central bankers to judge when they should abandon their economic outlook, often arrived at through months of internal debate and calculation.

Bernanke, 53, is an expert in inflation-targeting and has spent much of his career in academia. He is flanked at the Washington-based Board of Governors by Randall Kroszner, a former University of Chicago Business School professor, and Frederic Mishkin, a monetary policy researcher and professor from the Graduate School of Business at Columbia University in New York.

Vice Chairman Donald Kohn, formerly the Fed's director of the Division of Monetary Affairs from 1987 to 2001, is the only governor with high-level experience in financial-crisis management. Kohn, 64, joined a conference call Geithner convened with bankers on Aug. 17 to persuade them to take advantage of the lower discount rate.

Geithner's Experience
Among executives of the district banks, Geithner, 46, has the most extensive background in responding to upheavals. During the Clinton years, he was an aide to Robert Rubin and Lawrence Summers, who both served as Treasury secretary. In that role, Geithner helped broker emergency loans for Thailand, Indonesia, South Korea, Russia and Brazil when their currencies sagged. While he was at the Treasury, the U.S. participated in interventions to strengthen the yen in 1998, and the euro in 2000.

``It is a team that is new to the challenge, but it is a pretty smart group,'' said Harris. Bernanke ``really studied for the job. He is familiar with the history of the Fed, the policy errors, and he is a Great Depression buff.'' Bernanke contributed to Depression research with a 1999 paper co-authored with Mark Gertler and Simon Gilchrist on how financial markets can worsen economic downturns.

With Friday's action, Bernanke and his colleagues have ``tip-toed in'' and are ``trying to strike the right balance between doing nothing and riding to the rescue,'' said Gary Schlossberg, senior economist at Wells Fargo Capital Management in San Francisco, which oversees $200 billion in assets. ``They've left the door open to a full-blown easing of monetary policy. The results are mixed so far, and early returns suggest we're not out of the woods yet.''

Friday, August 17, 2007

Retrospection - Fed's decision to keep rates at 5.25%

Fed Gives Weak Nod to Growth and Credit Risks: Caroline Baum
By Caroline Baum


Aug. 8 (Bloomberg) -- Fed to market: You made your bed, you lie in it.

That was the essence of the Federal Reserve's message yesterday when it left its benchmark lending rate unchanged at 5.25 percent and said inflation remains the ``predominant policy concern.''

Ever since the stock market started to get wobbly in late July, with losses in the Dow Jones Industrial Average exceeding 200 points some days, interest-rate futures markets got it in their head that Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke was going to bail them out.

The message yesterday was: Not so fast. Policy makers gave the weakest possible nod to the volatility in the markets and ``tighter credit conditions for some households and businesses'' without tipping their hand, or their risk assessment, away from inflation.

In the Fed's view, the ``downside risks to growth have increased somewhat'' as the housing correction continues. Inflation in goods-and-services prices is still more troubling than deflation in asset prices (specifically housing). The decline in nationwide home prices has been mild to date, but it is certain to accelerate as the bloated supply of unsold homes comes face to face with reduced demand, with credit-tightening shutting some borrowers out of the market.

The first reaction to the Fed's statement at 2:15 p.m. New York time was to sell. The prices of stocks, bonds, gold and interest-rate futures all went down initially as the Fed failed to corroborate the view that the economic environment was deteriorating rapidly.

Antidote
Until now, ``the Fed has been pretty good at describing the theme people were sensing,'' said Jim Glassman, senior U.S. economist at JPMorgan Chase & Co. in New York. Yesterday's statement ``is out of character with the reality as we know it.''

That doesn't mean the Fed is living in a parallel universe. Policy makers have to differentiate between a financial-market event and a macroeconomic one. For the moment, they have determined that the weakness in residential real estate, the widening of credit spreads and tighter lending standards aren't a threat to economic growth.

The ``cure'' for a period of excess credit is credit restraint: from the Fed; from mortgage lenders, who are faced with rising delinquencies and increased foreclosures on the part of subprime, and now prime, borrowers; and from investors, who are suffering losses on opaque collateralized mortgage and debt obligations that were supposed to diffuse the risk of the underlying loans.

Tainted Inheritance
Bernanke inherited the housing bubble from predecessor Alan Greenspan, who seemed to be rewriting history and offloading some of the blame in yesterday's Wall Street Journal. (Greenspan's greatest problem right now is that his soon-to-be-published memoir, ``The Age of Turbulence,'' may arrive just as the foundation is collapsing.)

He also inherited an institutional burden from his predecessor. Greenspan has been accused of creating a moral hazard, or encouraging risky behavior by putting a floor under the stock market (the ``Greenspan put'').

It may well be that the current Fed chief needs to expiate the sins of the father. Bernanke earned himself the moniker ``Helicopter Ben,'' early on -- unjustly, in my view -- when he compared the Fed's money-creation process to a chopper dropping dollars from the sky.
That's right out of the Milton Friedman teaching toolkit. When was the last time anyone accused the University of Chicago economist and Nobel laureate of fanning inflation?

Base Case
For what it's worth, the Fed's provision of credit, or high- powered money, has slowed to a crawl. The monetary base, which includes currency and bank reserves, grew 2.1 percent in July from the same month a year earlier, according to the St. Louis Fed's database. That's less than the inflation rate. As recently as last year, base money was still growing in excess of 5 percent annually.

There has been some suggestion -- accusation, really -- that the current Fed board is populated with academics (Bernanke along with Fed Governors Frederic Mishkin and Randall Kroszner), and that academics lack Greenspan's innate instincts about the market.
Maybe. Not all of his gut reactions were good ones, however. Greenspan lowered the federal funds rate three times in the fall of 1998 to counter the ``seizing up'' of financial markets in response to the near-collapse of hedge fund Long-Term Capital Management.

The economy didn't miss a beat. Greenspan waited until May 1999 to remove that stimulus. In the meantime, the Nasdaq Composite Index was well on its way to an 86 percent gain for the year.

Gut Check
Greenspan was slow to cut rates when capital spending was imploding in 2000, then did so with a vengeance in 2001. The overnight rate was still at 1 percent when the economy was taking off. Real gross domestic product grew at a 7.5 percent annualized rate in the third quarter of 2003, the start of a three-year trend of strong growth. Yet Greenspan took his time moving the funds rate back to a neutral level.

The Bernanke Fed, with its model-driven forecast, may turn out to be wrong in its laissez-faire attitude toward tightening credit conditions. It will come to that decision in its own way in its own time.

The inverted yield curve, with long-term rates below the Fed's policy rate, has been signaling for almost a year that the Fed is holding the funds rate too high. That disequilibrium is always resolved in favor of lower short-term rates.

I doubt this time will be different. It never is.