Showing posts with label carried interest. Show all posts
Showing posts with label carried interest. Show all posts

Thursday, November 22, 2007

Japanese stock markets take a toll despite strengthening yen

Japan's Topix Falls 20% From 2007 High, Signaling Bear Market

By Elizabeth Stanton

Nov. 22 (Bloomberg) -- Japan became the first of the world's 10 biggest stock markets to enter a bear market when the Topix index declined 20 percent from its 2007 peak.

The 39-year-old Topix, the broadest gauge of equity prices in the world's second-largest economy, fell 2.1 percent yesterday to 1,438.72, the lowest since October 2005 and down 20.8 percent from its 2007 high of 1,816.97 on Feb. 26.

Japanese companies are struggling with slowing economic growth in the U.S., their largest market for exports, the yen's appreciation and record crude oil prices. The Topix decline from a 15-year high in February signals the government's efforts to revive the economy from more than a decade of inconsistent growth, have hit a snag, investors said.

``Performance potential is limited by a deteriorating economic outlook, both foreign and domestic,'' said Florence Barjou, Paris-based strategist at Lyxor Asset Management, which oversees $100 billion.

The Nikkei-225 Stock Average, created in 1949, is just short of bear market territory. It fell 2.5 percent yesterday to 14,837.66, the lowest since July 2006 and down 18.8 percent from a six-year high of 18,261.98, also on Feb. 26.

The Nikkei is a price-weighted average of 225 Japanese companies including Toyota Motor Corp, Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group and NTT Docomo Inc. with a median market value of 748.9 billion yen ($6.89 billion). The Topix is a capitalization- weighted index of 1,719 companies with a median market value of 469.8 trillion yen.

Less Than Stellar

The Topix decline ``would be an official bear market so to speak, but Japan hasn't been an area of stellar growth for 10 years,'' said Paul Hickey, managing partner at Bespoke Investment Group LLC in Harrison, New York.

Most stock markets have fallen this month, with the U.S. Standard & Poor's 500 Index down 8.6 percent, on pace for its worst month since September 2002. The declines reflect expectations that investment losses created by the biggest slump in housing since 1991 are curbing growth in the world's largest economy.

The MSCI World Index of developed-country shares is down 7.9 percent from a record on Oct. 31, and the MSCI Emerging Markets Index has fallen 11 percent from its high on Oct. 29.

Toyota, the Japanese company with the largest market value, fell 2.8 percent yesterday to a 16-month low amid concern U.S. sales will slow. Toyota is the second-biggest auto seller in the U.S. behind General Motors Corp.

Rising Yen

The yen has strengthened against all 16 major currencies since mid-year, making Japanese products more expensive in other countries. Against the dollar it has gained 9.8 percent, reaching a more than two-year high of 108.51 per dollar yesterday.

Losses in global credit-markets are fueling the yen's rise by spurring investors to sell higher-yielding assets that were purchased with yen borrowed at low interest rates and sold. The Bank of Japan's overnight call rate, the main rate at which banks lend to one another, is 0.5 percent, the lowest among the major economies.

Record crude oil prices, a problem for all manufacturing economies, are a particular disadvantage in Japan, which imports almost all of the oil it uses. Crude oil futures touched a record $99.29 a barrel in New York Mercantile Exchange trading yesterday, and are up 62 percent in the past year.

The Bank of Japan on Oct. 31 cut its growth estimate for the year ending in March to 1.8 percent from 2.1 percent. Reflecting reduced expectations for economic growth, the yield on 10-year Japanese government bonds yesterday fell to a 23-month low of 1.439 percent.

Investors in Japan's stock market have experienced worse over the past two decades than the drop from this year's peaks. In 1990, the Topix lost almost 40 percent of its value and the Nikkei lost almost 39 percent.

Tuesday, June 19, 2007

Another reactionary development - Congress targets tax planning on private equity firms and hedge funds

Fund Managers' Taxes May Rise as Senate Targets Fees Stratagem
By Ryan J. Donmoyer


June 19 (Bloomberg) -- Hedge-fund and private-equity managers, already under congressional scrutiny for the lower tax rate they pay on their profits, may also be targeted for a strategy they use to pay less on their management fees.

Congressional aides say the Senate Finance Committee is studying a technique that allows fund managers to qualify most or all of their income for the 15 percent capital-gains rate by structuring their management fee as a share of profits rather than a percentage of assets.

``Among the blue-chip managers, 70 percent do it,'' said Steven Howard, a partner at the New York law firm Thacher Proffitt & Wood LLP who advises investment firms. ``It's become prevalent in the last five years because of the huge amount of money these guys have made.''
The review is part of a broader inquiry by the Senate panel, which made its first major foray into overhauling the tax treatment of hedge funds and private-equity firms last week by introducing legislation that would more than double taxes for Blackstone Group LP and Fortress Investment Group LLC by 2012.

Traditionally, managers have required investors to pay a fee equivalent to 2 percent of a fund's assets, which is then taxed at ordinary rates of up to 35 percent. The managers also receive 20 percent of profits beyond a specified return amount, called ``carried interest,'' which is subject to the capital- gains rate.

Priority Allocation
To get the tax savings, fund managers agree to waive all or most of their management fees. In exchange, they later receive a priority allocation of net profits equivalent to the value of the waived fees. That payout, known as a special distribution, is subject to the 15 percent rate, according to Howard and other tax advisers.

Experts said the technique reduces the tax burden for fund managers, though it also exposes them to greater risk because the payout is contingent on the fund's profits. It also reduces the tax liability of individual investors, who can sidestep limits on deducting investment fees.

``Carry is a big deal for everyone because that's where the home runs are,'' said Simon Friedman, a tax partner in the Los Angeles office of Milbank, Tweed, Hadley & McCloy LLP who specializes in alternative investments.

A Central Element
The pay of managers is one of the central elements of the broader congressional examination of the tax structure of hedge funds and buyout firms, said Victor Fleischer, a University of Illinois tax professor who met with congressional staff in May. Fleischer said that while lawmakers are considering increasing taxes on carried interest, most have assumed that fund managers must pay higher tax rates on their fees.

``It all goes back to the fact that when a fund manager receives a profits interest, those distributions should probably be characterized as service income rather than investment income,'' Fleischer said.

Fleischer said he has made a ``back-of-the-envelope'' analysis based on assets of $1 trillion and an annual rate of return of 15 percent showing that fund managers are saving between $4 billion and $6 billion a year in taxes by paying capital-gains rates on their 20 percent carried interest. He wouldn't estimate how much they save by converting fees into profit shares, though he said the practice ``seems to be taken as standard.''

Lobbying Groups
Robert Stewart, vice president of public affairs for the Private Equity Council, a lobbying group in Washington, declined to comment.
Lisa McGreevy, executive vice president of the Managed Funds Association, the main Washington-based lobbying group for hedge funds, said she wasn't aware of the conversion technique. Still, she said the group is urging Congress to proceed with caution. ``The whole issue is fundamental to entrepreneurship in the United States and the ability to use sweat equity to build long-term investments,'' she said.
While most hedge funds make investments that produce short- term capital gains taxable at the top rate of 35 percent, many managers create longer-term ``side pocket'' investments for illiquid assets that qualify for the preferential 15 percent rate.

Friedman said the conversion of management fees raises questions about tax avoidance by individuals who invest in funds. Managers are sensitive to investor complaints that they can't write off investment fees as a miscellaneous deduction until those expenses exceed 2 percent of gross income, he said.

`Still a Problem'
``The 2 percent floor is still a problem for individuals,'' he said. Structuring the fee as a special distribution to the fund manager is equivalent to a deduction because the fund profits used to make the payment are never transferred to the investor as taxable income.
The conversion technique is described in a September 2001 presentation entitled ``Converting Management Fees Into Carried Interest'' prepared by the Palo Alto, California-based law firm Wilson Sonsini Goodrich & Rosati. The paper says the fee can be converted into carried interest ``without reducing cash flow or adding unacceptable risk.''

The presentation's author, Jonathan Axelrad, said in an interview that the technique generates tax advantages because fund managers assume more risk.

``If you reduce the economic risk you will increase the risk on the tax analysis,'' Axelrad said.